Deployment on-premise vs on-cloud
There are two ways to deploy a High-Performance Computing System. HPCs can be deployed on-premise where the organization sets up its own data center with clusters as per its demand. Another method of deployment is to avail the service of a cloud service provider to set up a virtual HPC on the cloud. To choose from among these types of deployment several factors such as location, setup costs, operational costs, etc. must be considered.
Setup Costs: The setup costs include the overall costs incurred in creating the hardware and software infrastructure for HPC development. These costs are relatively lower in the case of cloud-driven solutions compared to on-premise solutions. For example, Amazon Deep Learning and Amazon Marketplace Instances come completely configured with GPUs. To counter this on-premise HPC solutions from Dell or NVIDIA also aim to reduce these setup costs with their popular frameworks and open-source HPC stacks.
Operating and Capital Costs: In the early phase of projects, when experimentation of the model is the major focus the workload is relatively less. During this period the operational costs for both on-premise and on-cloud HPC are comparable. Advancing into further stages, when the workload increases, more intensive use of cloud services can spike the cost significantly. Hence, agencies are advised to conduct a Total Cost of Ownership analysis (TCO) for their project to choose the mode of deployment.
Data and Application Locality: Any machine learning application to be run on HPC will be handling large datasets in the size range of terabytes. Data needs to be ingested, cleaned and processed before use in training the model. For these processes, it is beneficial if the application and data reside at the same location. This reduces latencies, improves quality of service and reduces costs. However, if the teams employed to work with the data are distributed across the world, on-cloud HPC solutions can provide better accessibility.
Security and Privacy: Most Cloud service providers promise complete security and confidentiality of the user’s data. However, they are vulnerable to attacks when the system is online. Users can decide based on the sensitivity of their data whether they are comfortable with hosting it on-premise or on-cloud HPC.
Workload Demand: Projects, where there might be temporary surges in workload demand, can choose to deploy on-cloud. Cloud services offer flexibility to choose capacity and pay as per usage. Availing this facility is a cost-effective strategy for organizations as it prevents them from managing more compute capacity than needed.
Performance: The computing bandwidth offered in cloud service is equivalent to the computing capability of on-premise infrastructure. Latency in cloud services is generally low. However, if the user is accessing from a long distance it significantly degrades performance due to an increase in latency.
Last updated